Hard Determinism Vs. Negatives - 943 Words

Throughout the years, many different philosophical ideas have been presented to the general populace. One of these ideas, hard determinism, has presented alleged positives and alleged negatives. One alleged negative that stands out to me is that no single person is responsible for their actions, no matter how heinous that action may be. I argue, that throwing morality completely out of the equation, is a genuine negative of hard determinism. In order to explain my thoughts, we must first understand the full meaning of hard determinism. In Holbach’s essay on hard determinism, he says, â€Å"Nevertheless, in spite of the shackles by which he is bound, it is pretended he is a free agent, or that independent of the causes by which he is moved, he determines his own will, and regulates his own condition.†1 He explains that free will is an illusion and that all of our actions are pre-determined by prior factors. Prior factors would include: experiences from the past, h ow one was raised, genetic makeup and so on. No matter what you decide to do, you will never actually have a say in it because everything in your life has led up to that point. For example; if one man is walking down the street and bumps into another man, how the second man reacts will have been predetermined therefore not making him liable for those actions. Say he decides to accept the man’s apology and goes on with his day. This is due to the way he was raised and his genetic makeup, not because of his ownShow MoreRelatedSociology1220 Words   |  5 Pageshistorical says conservatives are ahistorical Static – concepts and ideas remain the same (opposite of dynamic) Family is not static because it is always changing Stop moralizing and start mobilizing mythmaking is not a solution Idealized past vs terrible present – saying that the past wasn’t everything that it was cracked up to be with statistics and that the present isn’t worse than the past although it may not be better Coltrane and gender – gender is tied together with the family GenderRead MorePsychology and Impact Personality Development1997 Words   |  8 Pagespersonality. * Besides this, economic factors i.e., economic condition of the family and the type of relations between the parents also influence the personality of the child. * (4) Cultural Environment * Individualism in westerners vs collectivism in Africa caused by environment * Striking difference in the universal trait of shyness caused by how each culture dealt with the child’s success and failures. * Who gets credit for good grades, gets blamed for not gettingRead MorePsychology and Impact Personality Development2008 Words   |  9 Pagesof personality. * Besides this, economic factors i.e., economic condition of the family and the type of relations between the parents also influence the personality of the child. * (4) Cultural Environment * Individualism in westerners vs collectivism in Africa caused by environment * Striking difference in the universal trait of shyness caused by how each culture dealt with the child’s success and failures. * Who gets credit for good grades, gets blamed for not gettingRead MoreEssay about Race, Class, and Gender: The Critical Race Theory2526 Words   |  11 Pagesthat race is central, not peripheral, to American thought and life. Second is the notion that racism is common and ordinary rather than rare and episodic, so that a great deal of Americans’ social life is affected by it. A third strand is material determinism, or interest convergence—the idea that racial relations maintain a white-over-black/brown hierarchy that provides benefits and profits to elite groups in the majority race and are for that reason difficult to reform. A fourth feature is the socialRead MoreJapanese Culture And Japanese People2323 Words   |  10 PagesRather than being passive receptors for cultural and linguistic knowledge, children and language learners actively participate and co-construct social worlds while achieving communicative competence. This is in contrast to views such as l inguistic determinism where grammatical forms are assumed to map directly onto social structures and interactions. Instead, each individual brings with them their own phenomenology and therefore engage in different ways. So even in a given formal school setting, eachRead MoreThe Cause of Globalization18688 Words   |  75 Pagesgoods and more notably information around the world, growing international economic activity, and the liberalization of foreign economic policies. What are the causal relationships among these three trends? The second perspective, technological determinism, contends that the shrinkage of time and space has been so dramatic and so pervasive that there is essentially nothing that can be done to stop it. According to this view, technological changes have propelled international economic activity, andRead MoreThe Effect of Genetic, Environmental and Cultural Factors on Learning2722 Words   |  11 Pagesbiologists, psychologists and socialists have theorized, experimented and offered explanations and approaches of their own interpretation of learning and development, based on many years of research. In addition, the argument of Nature vs. Nurture is of paramount importance to their research, findings and beliefs. Before starting to analyse what factors affect learning and development, I need to establish and define what learning and development actually mean. QuestionsRead MoreSelf Control5185 Words   |  21 Pagesevidence that self-control is a limited mental resource, a number of studies support the notion that self-control is nevertheless a resource that can be increased through suitable exercise. ------------------------------------------------- In children vs. adults Self control should increase with age due to the development of the sensory system. As the sensory system develops, peoples perceptual abilities expand. For instance, children do not have a concept of time, and in this sense, they live in theRead MoreCRM 1301 Midterm uOttawa Carolyn Gordon Essay10218 Words   |  41 Pagesentertainment Abuse of power Barbaric Based on pain Could be arrest w/o warrant, tortured for no reason, Jail without trial No sense of Due Process No codified law Critique of Criminal Justice during the 18th century Capital punishment Negative effect (on the general public) Reluctant to convict Deterrent effect (No general deterrent effect) Transportation What to do with all the prisoners Send offenders to Colonies Jails People who went to Jail had to pay for everything regardlessRead MoreJohn Gotti Received More Publicity Any Crime Figure, Discuss the Theories Developed by Merton and Sutherland and Compare and Contrast Regarding Which Would Describe Gottis Criminal Development4321 Words   |  18 Pagesdeviance in terms of the individual s social relationships. Sutherland s theory departs from the pathological perspective and biological perspective by attributing the cause of crime to the social context of individuals. He rejected biological determinism and the extreme individualism of psychiatry, as well as economic explanations of crime. His search for an alternative understanding of crime led to the development of differential association theory. In contrast to both classical and biological